South Fork

The South Fork reported 452 single-family home sales in First Quarter 2025, up 4% versus last quarter and 28% year-over-year. This was the largest number of closings since Third Quarter 2023 and the second consecutive quarter with an annual increase in sales—which has not occurred since Third Quarter 2021.

Compared to First Quarter 2024, 12 of 14 submarkets saw higher sales, with one submarket lower and the other level compared with last year. East Hampton Village had the greatest annual percentage gain, with closings doubling to 20 sales from 10 last year. Southampton Village was the only submarket to decline, down 14% (three fewer sales).

Dollar volume increased alongside sales, rising 34% year-over-year to $1.465B. Annually, 11 submarkets reported increases in volume while three declined. Southampton exhibited the largest annual percentage gain, as closings reported over $5M grew from two to five, with one sale reaching $10M. Westhampton Beach, Quogue, and Montauk were the only submarkets to report a decline in sales volume. Westhampton Beach’s decline was most significant, down 17% as just two sales closed above $5M compared to four in First Quarter 2024.

Median price increased 5% year-over-year, back on track with growth after an unusual decline last quarter. Median price has increased annually in six of the past seven quarters.

Compared to a year ago, median price expanded in half of the 14 South Fork submarkets. Southampton’s median price changed most significantly, up 47% with three sales topping $6M, compared to zero last year. Notably, 24 Jule Pond Drive, a lakefront six-bedroom home, closed for $10M. Westhampton/Remsenburg had the largest percentage decrease in median price of any village/hamlet, down 31% annually because of a smaller share of sales above $3M.

North Fork

North Fork single-family home sales expanded 17% annually to 116 closings in First Quarter 2025. Nevertheless, half of the submarkets reported annual increases. Cutchogue had the most significant percentage increase on the North Fork, up 67%, from 12 to 20 sales versus last year. East Marion/Orient sales fell most significantly, down 18% (two sales). This was the first annual increase for the North Fork after sales declined or remained level for the previous four quarters.

Four of six North Fork submarkets saw sales volume increase versus 2024 due to rising prices. Cutchogue increased most significantly in sales volume, up 104% to $38.976M. East Marion/Orient had the largest annual decline in volume, down 32% primarily due to fewer sales in the submarket.

Overall, median price ticked slightly higher by 1% year-over-year to $995K. However, average price increased more significantly by 14%, bolstered by double the number of sales above $3M in the North Fork. Nevertheless, average price was still 7% below its peak in Fourth Quarter 2024.

The Residential Luxury Market

The luxury market is the top 10% of all home sales by price during the quarter. As various factors redefine the high-end market in any given period, price figures may exhibit more volatility than the market overall. However, because the luxury market is a fixed percentage of the overall market, its changes in the number of sales will always match the overall market.

In First Quarter 2025, South Fork luxury average price ticked slightly higher by 2%, up to $12.9M. Median price decreased by 10% to $9.1M due to a larger share of sales below $2M.

First Quarter 2025’s most expensive reported sale was a 10,000 square foot compound with 220 feet of direct ocean frontage at 370 & 372 Further Lane in Amagansett, closing for $70M. Water Mill accounted for more of the South Fork’s luxury sales than any other submarket, with 10 closings, including a $16.5M sale at 34 Cobb Isle Road. Bridgehampton/Sagaponack and East Hampton Village each had eight luxury sales.

The average luxury sale price on the North Fork increased 22% annually, and median price jumped 41% year-over-year. Last year, only three sales were reported over $3M; this year, that number more than doubled to seven. On the North Fork, the highest-priced sale was a five-bedroom, five-bathroom residence on Cutchogue Harbor with 100 feet of beachfront, trading for $6.4M.